The Old Jace is dead; long live Jace. Been a long time since I posted something, and it's been a long time since I was excited for a Magic set. Lorwyn was a fun respite from the barrage of non-fantasy UB sets that followed and preceded it. I know Strixhaven came out, but I wasn't big on the first Strixhaven set and didn't have strong feelings about its return.
When this set was announced at Magic Con Vegas, I was standing in the hall as they made the announcement. I was in awe with the concept of an alternate reality set. Alongside the artwork, the gears started turning. The possibility of a ton of weird designs and mechanics appearing as a different iteration had me hungry to know more. Though the list below doesn't reflect this, it delivered on that promise.
| This just reminds me of the poster for MVC2 |
For every set, I look at all the new cards being released. So whether it is in the main set or supplementary, I am evaluating all of it.
I rank the cards based on both power level and innovation. When evaluating by power level, I'm scaling it off of unpowered vintage. By innovation, I mean cards that either smooth out the deck building and drafting by overlapping into a bunch of decks or opening up new archetypes in cube. The cards need to still be powerful or at least playable, as they need to still be competitive versus other cards. Ultimately, your cube, your choices, address your needs. You may not even need to get anything from the set.
New for this article, I am including a separate evaluation for cards in a multiplayer environment when needed.
The List
Chandra, Chill of Compliance reminds me of Jace, the Mind Sculptor, but tighter and more niche. The card will excel in environments heavy in blue (and really any color) doing noncreature things, which is growing. The draw and ramp are always good; keeping the card versatile and easy to slot into many decks. The draw can also function as a graveyard filler for creatures as well. The tap ability interest me since you can stun artifacts and creatures. Being able to delay or force activated abilities is sometimes the call when removal isn't effective. Cards that come to mind are Mother of Runes and Retrofitter's Foundry. All this for 3 mana is pretty good to me, not slam dunk yet, but I'm high on its impact.
Theorist's Sanctum is a fetchable land with late-game play. Card filtering/ advantage is essential if you plan on playing longer games, and having it on a fetchable land is a perfect place to have it. Unless you used your Jace token in the same turn, most empower cards read as surveilling 1 if the loyalty is 2 or less, or draw a card if 3 or more. The main point of contention is the land coming into play untapped. Based on my experiences, it's entering tapped most of the time because there aren't enough Jaces in a cube to consistently behold. In a slower environment, I would include it; otherwise, this is a tough sell.
Emrakul, the Exigent Doom is the big scary fatty to cheat in for the set. This might be the least devastating one. Unlike the others, it doesn't have a crippling effect on your opponent upon cast/entry. It is that last bit of text where I think it outdoes its competition. Though not the most efficient, you can "adventure" the card and let it be mana ramp until you cast it. It can be cast at instant speed to keep it a surprise, and as an ability, it is difficult to interact with. If they counter it, you do lose the card. Having this function solves the problem all cards from this category have: they are generally dead cards until they're on the battlefield. This makes it the most consistently playable and therefore the most versatile one of this group. You're losing out on explosiveness for consistency. This makes the card worth testing. I'm hesitant that it won't feel as good to cheat it out, but that's it.
Vigorbloom Charm can be seen as an updated Dromoka's Charm. I like this over Dromoka's charm for the cantrip and more universal creature protection. These changes make the card significantly more playable in a color combination that has been struggling in my cubes.
Fatehold Charm feels like the Azorius Charm I always wanted, but never knew how to approach it. The card is much easier to play than its predecessor with all of the modes fitting into various versions of UW. The anthem is a nice touch since UW in recent years has been able to pull off aggressive starts and finishes. This just helps them get there faster or stops toughness-based board wipes from ruining their day. I need to find space for this.
Way of the Pyromancer is effectively a full 2 mana planeswalker that helps you ramp and draw cards in red. Surveil has already proven powerful, so there's not much to say. Some other players have compared it to mindstone, which I agree with in a vacuum. It gets significantly better if you have a sizeable amount of other planeswalkers. It also does come in as 2 permanents (a legendary enchantment and a planeswalker token) for interactions that care about that. So slower cubes will definitely get a lot of mileage out of this card.
Liliana the Faultless was something I immediately dismissed and after playing it I understood how wrong I was. She's Soul Warden combined with Giver of Runes on a discard outlet. She's everything cube curators wanted a long time ago. Even with the recent design changes and power creep, she still fills a niche, while being versatile. I'm including her in my cubes.
Ajani Unrelenting is an upgraded Chandra, Flamecaller. When Flamecaller was printed, I thought her design was so good because it opened red up into a control style of play. Over time, the card would fall from grace; it couldn't stabilize the game, and your opponent could still win. Ajani solves this issue with the passive by always gaining a creature. In a vacuum, I've taken over games with just this card. If there is even one other planeswalker on the board, this card becomes exponentially better. Will test for 1v1, but multiplayer is a definite inclusion.




Comments
Post a Comment